ScaleCrafts

Design live comments

Show viewers of a live video the comments everyone else is posting, in real time, like Facebook Live or YouTube Live chat.

Functional requirements

  • Post a comment on a live video
  • See new comments within a second
  • Load recent comments when joining

Non-functional requirements

  • Comments appear in under 1 second
  • Works for streams with 1M viewers
  • Spam is limited

Scale

  • 1M concurrent live videos
  • Popular streams have millions of viewers
  • Thousands of comments per second on big streams

How you’ll be scored

9 checks covering your diagram and your notes, and any valid approach counts. Hints appear for anything you miss. Common mistakes, such as single points of failure or components you never explain, cost points. How grading works

What interviewers look for

  • Clarify before you draw. State what is in and out of scope. For “Design live comments”, that starts with: Post a comment on a live video; See new comments within a second; Load recent comments when joining. Interviewers notice candidates who pin the requirements down first.
  • Turn the scale into numbers. The scale (1M concurrent live videos; Popular streams have millions of viewers; Thousands of comments per second on big streams) should become requests per second, storage and bandwidth, and those figures should drive your choices. Estimates with units carry more weight than adjectives.
  • Show how each quality is met. Your design should visibly deliver: Comments appear in under 1 second; Works for streams with 1M viewers; Spam is limited. Saying that it does isn’t enough; point to the part of the design that makes it true.
  • Expect follow-ups on the hard parts. Interviewers usually probe real-time, pub/sub and fan-out here. This is a medium problem, so interviewers expect you to weigh two reasonable options, such as consistency against latency, and to say why you picked one.
  • Explain failure and trade-offs. Say what happens when a component fails, where a single point of failure would hurt, and what you chose not to build. Naming a trade-off is a stronger answer than claiming there isn’t one.

Related problems

Loading your workspace…